
In a world where a thumbs-up has become the new gold star, it’s easy to forget that criticism—when given with care—can often be more valuable than praise. It’s like choosing sugar over medicine: the sweet taste feels good, but it’s the bitter dose that often helps us heal and grow.
Recently, I attended a program organized by my wife’s dance school. The event was meant to honour the late Sri B V K Shastry, a towering figure in the world of performing arts criticism. Many speakers took to the stage—some were his peers, others were seasoned dancers who had been reviewed by him.
The stories were striking. His colleagues spoke about his brilliance, his approachability, and his relentless dedication. But when it came to the dancers, a different theme emerged. They recalled how he always found something that needed improvement in their performances, rarely giving out compliments. At first glance, this might sound harsh, almost like rain on a parade. But here’s the twist—every single one of them credited him as a key force behind their success. Why? Because he saw not just what they were, but what they could be.
Criticism: The Tough Coach in the Gym of Life
This reminded me of my early days at Bosch (then known as MICO), back in 1986. At that time, we considered a “no criticism” review a major win. Praise was as rare as a desert flower. We used to joke that we were like donkeys chasing a carrot tied to a stick—always running, never quite getting it. But we kept running. And with every step, we became faster, sharper, and better. What seemed like an endless chase turned out to be the very path that led us to growth.
Back then, criticism wasn’t seen as an attack—it was a tool. Yes, it stung sometimes, but it was the kind of sting that woke you up and got you moving. Like a personal trainer shouting “one more rep!”—not to break you, but to break your limits.
The Fragile Flower of Today’s Talent
Fast forward to today, and I sometimes wonder—have we grown too soft for criticism? I remember a young engineer we had hired from a top institute. During routine site visits, we would point out deviations in his work. Instead of taking it in stride, he began to spiral into stress and anxiety, eventually needing medication just to sleep. In a heart-to-heart conversation, he broke down and said something that stayed with me: “I always got top marks all through school and college. Now, I feel like I’m worth nothing because I can’t meet your expectations.”
He wasn’t lazy. He wasn’t incompetent. He was simply unprepared for a world where likes aren’t guaranteed, and applause doesn’t come easy.
Failure: The Unseen Foundation of Resilience
Somewhere along the line, it seems we’ve wrapped children in bubble wrap—protecting them from falls, but also from the strength that comes from rising after them. I sometimes feel that experiencing failures early in life—and learning to bounce back from them—is as vital as learning the alphabet. Every fall teaches balance. Every scratch teaches caution. Every missed goal teaches strategy. These small failures act like little earthquakes, shaking us just enough to help us build emotional muscle and mental resilience. Without them, we risk becoming glass sculptures—beautiful to look at, but fragile when touched.
When children grow up only hearing applause and gold-star praise, they may reach adulthood unready for the necessary knocks of reality. Criticism, even when constructive, can then feel like a wrecking ball rather than a chisel. But when they’ve had a chance to stumble, to be told “not quite,” and to rise again—they learn to treat criticism not as a verdict, but as guidance.
Structured Feedback as a Catalyst for Growth
This idea of criticism as a constructive tool is something we’ve actively built into the doHow® Inspirational Persuasion Game. Instead of top-down evaluations, players experience subtle yet powerful forms of feedback from their peers. Everyone gets a chance to score each other on qualities like Clarity and Conviction, Openness and Authenticity, Humility and Compassion, Energy and Enthusiasm, and even on being Brief and to the Point or Within One’s Circle of Influence. It’s like holding up many mirrors—each offering a reflection from a slightly different angle.
These collective scoring tasks are not about ranking or comparison but about reflection and encouragement. Players also score each other on Active Listening, Supporting, and Participating, which brings a spirit of community learning. Every score is paired with improvement suggestions—not as corrections, but as nudges. Over time, this gamified, Socratic approach builds a feedback-rich culture where criticism doesn’t sting—it inspires. The feedback becomes less like a slap and more like a gentle steering of the wheel.
Are We Building Echo Chambers Instead of Stronger Minds?
Social media has taught us to chase hearts, thumbs-ups, and smiley faces. We post, we wait, we refresh—seeking instant approval like a hungry child waiting for candy. But in doing so, are we building echo chambers that reflect only what we want to hear, not what we need to hear?
Great critics—like Sri B V K Shastry—and great mentors, like the ones I had at Bosch, were not in the business of doling out empty praise. They were more like mirrors: they didn’t flatter you, but they showed you your true reflection, with all its flaws and all its potential. And they did it with compassion, not cruelty.
Likes Fade. Growth Lasts.
At times, I find myself quietly wishing that more of us experience early failures that teach us to bounce back stronger. I wish we grow up understanding that being told we’re not yet there is not a rejection—it’s an invitation. I wish our children, and the young minds entering the workforce, come across mentors who hold them to high standards with kindness, not just hand out stars with smiles. I wish we nurture more environments—like what we try to do with doHow®—where feedback is like water: clear, flowing, and life-giving.
How often do you welcome criticism to improve and grow and how often do you use criticism to get your team to discover their potential?
Happy reading!